AccordHK · Blog

AccordHK · Field notes

Following Apple, Google Also Requires Developers to Disclose In-App Random Item Draw Odds

Google has followed Apple in requiring developers to disclose the odds of obtaining virtual items through in-app random draws. Greater transparency is intended to help users make spending decisions, although the impact on gaming app revenue and the accuracy of published odds remain uncertain.

Historical article. Product claims, platform details, and timing advice in this article have not been verified for today.

Stock photo
Photo: Pexels

In brief

Google has followed Apple in requiring developers to disclose in-app random draw odds so users can assess their chances before spending. The article reports that the revenue impact remains uncertain and that verifying published odds against actual game mechanics appears difficult.

After Apple required developers to disclose the probability distribution for obtaining virtual items through random draws in apps, Google followed suit with the same requirement.

Perhaps also prompted by growing concerns over spending in games, Google recently added a requirement to its developer guidelines to disclose the probability distribution for obtaining virtual items through random draws in apps. Developers must clearly disclose these probabilities whenever users obtain virtual items through any random draw within an app, so users understand their chances of receiving a desired virtual item with a single purchase. Making probability information transparent helps users decide whether to continue spending money on opportunities to draw virtual items.

Before this, Apple had already explicitly required developers in China to publicly disclose the odds of obtaining virtual items through random draws in apps. It later extended this requirement to all content listed on the App Store.

These rules arose because an increasing number of mobile games have embraced random draws for obtaining virtual items that give users a greater advantage in the game or make it easier to complete levels, thereby encouraging purchases. However, too many players subsequently became drawn to the chance of winning big with a small outlay through random draws, leading to excessive spending. As a result, a number of local governments have begun discussing whether such in-game mechanics should be considered gambling, prompting Apple and Google to pay attention to these issues.

As for whether requiring developers to disclose the detailed odds of obtaining virtual items through random draws will affect the distribution of revenue from gaming apps, this remains uncertain for now. However, the requirement is expected to help curb misconduct by companies that profit from unfair probability distributions. That said, it also appears difficult to verify whether the probability details companies choose to publish match those actually used in their games.

https://www.inside.com.tw/2017/12/26/apple-app-store-loot-boxes-google

Frequently asked questions

What does Google require developers to disclose?

Google requires developers to disclose the probability distribution for obtaining virtual items through random draws in apps. Users must be clearly informed of these odds whenever they use such draws.

How does disclosing random draw odds help users?

It helps users understand the chance of obtaining a desired virtual item with a single purchase. This information allows them to make more informed decisions about whether to continue spending on draws.

What had Apple required before Google followed suit?

Apple had already required developers in China to publicly disclose the odds of obtaining virtual items through in-app random draws. It subsequently extended the requirement to all content listed on the App Store.

Why were these random draw mechanics attracting scrutiny?

The article describes excessive spending by players seeking a chance to win big with a small outlay. A number of local governments had begun discussing whether these in-game mechanics should be considered gambling.

Would disclosing odds affect gaming app revenue?

At the time of the article, the effect on revenue distribution remained uncertain. The requirement was expected to curb companies profiting from unfair odds, but verifying whether published odds matched those used in games appeared difficult.

More from the AccordHK blog.

AccordHK

Make the next step practical.

Talk with AccordHK about software delivery, AI workflows, or focused training.

✆